Have you noticed that some employees seem to be treated differently by managers? Do other employees complain about this?  Understanding the favoritism meaning is essential for anyone involved in managing or working within a team. In this blog we will explore what is favoritism, and its impact in the work culture.

What is the Definition of Favoritism?

Favoritism in the workplace is the practice of giving preferential treatment to certain employees based on personal bias rather than job performance or merit. 

The favoritism meaning encompasses actions where decisions related to promotions, assignments, or rewards are influenced by favoritism, leading to unfair advantages for some employees while others are overlooked despite their qualifications or contributions.

It can undermine fairness and lead to a toxic work environment, where performance is not the primary factor in decision-making. This can also decrease overall performance across the team, as employees may lose trust in the leadership and become disengaged.

Why is Understanding Favoritism Important for HR, Business Owners, and Team Leaders?

Understanding favoritism is crucial for HR professionals, small business owners, and team leaders because it directly affects the fairness, morale, and overall productivity of the workplace. 

When favoritism is not recognized and addressed, it can lead to a toxic work environment, diminished employee engagement, and reduced performance across the board. Here’s why it’s essential to define and understand favoritism in various organizational contexts:

  • Favoritism at work can severely affect employee mental health. Employees who feel overlooked or unfairly treated may experience stress, anxiety, and depression.
  • This can lead to a lack of motivation and decreased participation in workplace activities, which negatively impacts the overall work environment.
  • Favoritism can lead to legal challenges if it results in discriminatory practices.
  • By recognizing and addressing favoritism, HR and leaders can better allocate resources and employee support through initiatives like Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs).

Types of Favoritism

Favoritism can manifest in various forms within the workplace, each with distinct implications for employee morale, productivity, and the overall work environment. Here are some of them:

  • Nepotism: Nepotism is a form of favoritism where family members or relatives are given preferential treatment over other employees. This might include hiring, promotions, or assignment of desirable projects based on familial connections rather than merit or qualifications. 
  • Cronyism: Cronyism occurs when individuals in positions of power favor their close friends or associates over others, regardless of their qualifications or performance. This can result in unqualified or underperforming employees receiving benefits such as promotions, raises, or special privileges. 
  • In-Group Favoritism: In-group favoritism refers to the preferential treatment of employees who share similar characteristics, backgrounds, or beliefs with those in leadership positions. This could be based on shared educational backgrounds, cultural similarities, or even similar personality traits. 
  • Sexual Favoritism: Sexual favoritism involves preferential treatment based on romantic or sexual relationships between an employee and someone in a position of power. This form of favoritism can lead to legal challenges and create a toxic work environment.
  • Performance-Based Favoritism: While less commonly discussed, performance-based favoritism can occur when high-performing employees are consistently given more opportunities and benefits, often at the expense of others.

How Does Favoritism Influence Workplace Productivity?

In the favoritism game, there’s no one benefitting from it. One may believe that the person being treated that way gets something out of it (monetary compensation, faster promotions, etc.), but the truth is that they are also losing lessons from feedback, not proving themselves in challenging situations, and losing positive relationships with their peers.

Here’s a list of consequences that favoritism has in the workplace:

  • Employees who feel that their efforts and contributions are being overlooked in favor of others may become disengaged.
  • Favoritism can disrupt team dynamics, leading to inefficiencies in how work is distributed and completed. 
  • The presence of favoritism can negatively affect employee mental health. Those who are not favored may experience feelings of inadequacy, stress, and anxiety.
  • Over time, favoritism can erode the competitive edge of the organization as high-performing employees may seek opportunities elsewhere where they do feel valued.

Real-World Examples of Favoritism in the Workplace

Now that you have a clearer definition of favoritism at work, here are some examples of favoritism that can help you identify it and act quicker:

  • A manager consistently promotes a particular employee over others, regardless of their qualifications or performance. Other employees, despite being more qualified or having a better performance record, are overlooked, leading to resentment and decreased morale within the team.
  • In team management, a leader might regularly assign the most desirable or high-profile projects to a favored employee. This practice can demotivate other employees, who may feel that their skills and efforts are not recognized, leading to decreased engagement and productivity.
  • An HR professional may apply workplace policies inconsistently, favoring certain employees. For instance, a favored employee might receive more flexible work hours or be excused from following certain company rules, such as deadlines or dress codes. 
  • A manager might consistently offer learning opportunities to a particular employee while neglecting others. This can hinder the career progression of non-favored employees and reduce the overall skill level within the team, impacting long-term productivity and engagement.
  • In some cases, managers may give recognition and rewards, such as "Employee of the Month" awards, only to those employees they personally favor, regardless of actual performance. This selective recognition can demoralize other employees.

How Can Favoritism Impact Employee Mental Health?

The Equity Theory in psychology, developed by J. Stacy Adams, provides a framework for understanding the impact of favoritism on employee mental health. 

According to this theory, individuals seek fairness in their work relationships, comparing their inputs (e.g., effort, skill, time) and outputs (e.g., rewards, recognition) to those of others. When employees perceive an imbalance, this perceived inequity can lead to emotional distress, dissatisfaction, and reduced motivation. 

Here’s a detailed list of how this practice can affect employees’ mental health:

  • When employees see that rewards, promotions, or opportunities are not based on merit but on personal biases, they may feel powerless and uncertain about their future in the company. 
  • Employees who are not favored may begin to doubt their abilities and worth, leading to lowered self-esteem and confidence. 
  • Favoritism can disrupt team dynamics and collaboration, leading to a less cohesive and effective work environment.
  • Employees who feel that the system is rigged against them may become disengaged, withdrawing from their work and colleagues. 
  • Those who are favored may be resented by their peers, while those who are not may harbor negative feelings towards management. 
  • This uncertainty can exacerbate stress, leading to anxiety and, in some cases, depression.

FAQS: Favoritism

How does an EAP help with favoritism?

Despite not being the only solution to favoritism, an EAP offers support to employees dealing with the stress and anxiety caused by it by providing counseling and resources to help them cope. It supports people’s mental well-being and prevents long-term negative impacts on their work performance.

How should favoritism be managed at work?

Favoritism should be managed through transparency and fairness. Managers need to make decisions based on merit, regularly review their practices, and maintain open communication to ensure all employees feel valued and treated equally.

How can favoritism be prevented or addressed?

To prevent or address favoritism, establish clear policies, provide training on unbiased decision-making, and set up anonymous reporting systems. Regular audits and feedback can also help ensure fairness in the workplace.

How can training address issues related to favoritism?

Training can help by educating managers and employees on the effects of favoritism and teaching them how to make objective, merit-based decisions. It also raises awareness of unconscious biases that could lead to favoritism.

How can companies create policies around favoritism?

Companies should create clear, detailed policies that define favoritism and outline acceptable behaviors. These policies should include reporting procedures and protections against retaliation, ensuring they are regularly reviewed and enforced.

What role does favoritism play in workplace morale and mental health?

Favoritism can lower workplace morale and harm employee mental health by creating feelings of unfairness and resentment. Addressing it is crucial to maintaining a positive, equitable work environment where all employees are motivated and engaged.

‍